Is sitting with righteous people, standing in holy places, or walking in upright counsel praiseworthy if done for personal enjoyment rather than for the sake of Heaven?
Synopsis
Even ostensibly virtuous activities — associating with the righteous — are 'not praiseworthy' if motivated by personal pleasure rather than divine service. However, authorities note there is still benefit in doing so.
More in All Actions for the Sake of Heaven
Is it permitted to take an afternoon nap (shenat hatzohoraim) to enable Torah study?
2 opinions
What is the maximum permitted duration of an afternoon nap?
2 opinions
Must one recite the blessing 'Elohai neshamah' upon waking from an afternoon nap?
2 opinions
Should one recite 'Yehi noam' (Psalm 90:17 ff.) before an afternoon nap?
4 opinions
Is eating or drinking for one's own pleasure (without intent for the sake of Heaven) praiseworthy or permissible?
3 opinions
What must be the intent for marital relations (tashmish)? Is fulfilling desire or procreating for one's own benefit acceptable?
3 opinions
What intent is required for conversation and speech, including discussing words of wisdom?
3 opinions
Is the overall obligation to direct all actions toward the sake of Heaven (l'shem shamayim) a formal halakhic requirement or a pious aspiration (middat chassidut)?
2 opinions
Related from other topics
Must one say Havineinu standing, or is sitting or walking permitted?
Weekday Prayer Variations
Must Nefilat Apayim be performed sitting, or may it be done standing?
Ashrei and U'Va L'Tzion
How should one put on an undergarment (chaluq) in the morning — while lying down, sitting, or standing?
Washing Hands Upon Waking
Should the arm tefillin be put on sitting or standing, and the head tefillin standing?
When to Put On Tefillin
When giving the purse to a cheresh, shoteh, or katan, must one employ the same method as with the donkey (give while walking, take back while standing)?
Kiddush — Where and When
Should Havdalah be recited while sitting or standing?
Havdalah
Discussion
Discussion coming soon.
The Daily Law
One question. Every opinion. Every morning.
A new halakhic question and the full spectrum of rabbinic thought, delivered daily.